Does a Clinical Negligence Claim Have to Go to Court?

Table of Contents

CLMedilaw Insights

When it comes to medical negligence claims, one of the common concerns that individuals have is whether their case will have to go to court. The prospect of facing a trial can be daunting, but it’s important to understand that not all clinical negligence claims end up in court proceedings. In fact, the majority of cases are resolved through settlement negotiations. In this article, we will explore the process of clinical negligence claims and address the question, “Does a clinical negligence claim have to go to court?”

How many medical negligence claims go to court?

The number of medical negligence claims that go to court is relatively low. Most claims are settled before reaching the trial stage. The parties involved, including the claimant and the defendant, often prefer to negotiate a settlement rather than proceeding to court proceedings. These settlements are typically reached through discussions and negotiations between the legal representatives of both sides.

Settling a case out of court has several advantages. It allows for a quicker resolution, reducing the time and costs associated with a trial. Additionally, settlement negotiations provide an opportunity for the parties to reach a mutually agreeable outcome. The defendant may choose to offer a settlement if they believe the claimant has a strong case, or the claimant may accept a settlement to avoid the uncertainty and potential risks associated with a trial.

What type of clinical negligence cases tend to go to court?

While most clinical negligence claims are resolved outside of court, there are certain types of cases that are more likely to proceed to court proceedings. These cases tend to be complex and involve significant disputes between the parties. Examples include cases where it is challenging to prove negligence or cases where the claimant and defendant cannot agree on the appropriate compensation amount.

In situations where the parties cannot reach a settlement through negotiation, court proceedings may be necessary to resolve the dispute. It is important to note that even if a case goes to court, there is still a possibility of reaching a settlement at any stage of the trial process.

What is the medical negligence claims process?

The process of pursuing a clinical negligence claim typically begins by seeking legal representation from a qualified medical negligence solicitor. They will assess the viability of your claim and guide you through the necessary steps. Here is an overview of the typical medical negligence claims process:

Consultation and Assessment:

You consult with a medical negligence solicitor who will evaluate the details of your case, including reviewing relevant medical records and gathering supporting evidence.

Letter of Claim:

If your solicitor determines that your case has merit, they will draft a “letter of claim” detailing your allegations of clinical negligence. This letter is then sent to the defendant, usually the medical professional or healthcare provider responsible for your care.

Response from the Defendant:

The defendant has a set period to respond to the letter of claim. They may admit or deny clinical negligence. If negligence is admitted, the parties will work towards reaching a settlement. If negligence is denied, further legal action may be required.

Court Proceedings:

If a settlement cannot be reached, your solicitor may initiate court proceedings by issuing a claim in court. This marks the formal start of the litigation process.

Case Management:

The court may schedule case management hearings to establish timelines, discuss evidence, and address any outstanding issues.

Trial Preparation:

Both parties prepare their cases by gathering evidence, conducting witness interviews, and building their arguments. This phase may involve expert opinions and further negotiations.


If the case proceeds to trial, it will be presented before a judge. The judge will evaluate the evidence, listen to witness testimonies, and make a decision based on the merits of the case.

What happens when a clinical negligence claim goes to court?

When a clinical negligence claim goes to court, it typically involves multiple hearings and stages. These may include case management conferences, cost budgeting hearings, pre-trial case management hearings, small claims hearings, disposal hearings, and contested trials. The exact progression of the case will depend on its complexity and the decisions made by the court.

Throughout the court process, it is essential to have experienced legal representation. Your medical negligence solicitor will guide you through the proceedings, represent your interests, and provide support and advice. They will work diligently to present your case effectively and strive to achieve the best possible outcome.

How is medical negligence compensation calculated by the courts?

Medical negligence compensation awarded by the courts is determined based on several factors. The court considers the severity of your injuries, the impact on your life, and the financial losses you have suffered. Compensation is typically divided into two categories:


General Damages: This category covers compensation for pain, suffering, and the long-term effects of the negligence. The court will assess the impact of the negligence on your physical and emotional well-being.


Special Damages: Special damages include financial losses resulting from the negligence. This may include medical expenses, rehabilitation costs, loss of earnings, and future care needs. The court will consider the past and future financial implications of the negligence.

The court’s calculation of medical negligence compensation aims to provide appropriate redress for the harm suffered, both physically and financially.

How long does a medical negligence claim take?

The duration of a medical negligence claim can vary significantly depending on various factors. A relatively straightforward claim may be resolved within a few months, especially if the parties reach a settlement early in the process. However, more complex cases, especially those that go to trial, can take several years to conclude.

The length of a claim is influenced by factors such as the complexity of the medical issues involved, the availability of evidence, the court’s schedule, and the willingness of the parties to negotiate. An experienced medical negligence solicitor can provide an estimate of the likely timeline based on the specific circumstances of your case.

How can a medical negligence solicitor help with my claim?

Navigating a medical negligence claim can be complex and challenging. A knowledgeable and experienced medical negligence solicitor can provide invaluable assistance throughout the process. Here are some ways in which they can help:

Evaluation: A solicitor will assess the viability of your claim, determining if you have reasonable prospects of success.

Evidence Gathering: They will gather the necessary evidence, including medical records, witness statements, and expert opinions, to support your claim.

Negotiation: Your solicitor will engage in settlement negotiations with the defendant’s legal representatives, aiming to secure a fair and reasonable compensation offer.

Court Proceedings: If a settlement cannot be reached, your solicitor will guide you through court proceedings, representing your interests, and presenting your case before the court.

Support and Guidance: Throughout the process, your solicitor will keep you informed, provide advice, and answer any questions or concerns you may have. They will strive to alleviate any stress or anxiety associated with pursuing a clinical negligence claim.

Choosing the right medical negligence solicitor is crucial to the success of your claim. Look for solicitors with expertise in medical negligence cases, a track record of successful outcomes, and a commitment to providing personalized and compassionate support to their clients.

In Conclusion

While clinical negligence claims can result in court proceedings, the majority of cases are resolved through settlement negotiations. The decision to pursue a trial depends on various factors, including the complexity of the case and the willingness of the parties to reach a settlement. By seeking the guidance of an experienced medical negligence solicitor, you can navigate the claims process with confidence and work towards achieving a fair resolution for your injuries and losses. Remember, every case is unique, and consulting a legal professional is essential to understand the specific circumstances surrounding your claim.

Contact Us

Call Us

Call a member of our clinical negligence team about your claim

Get in Touch

Contact a member of our clinical negligence team online

Keep up to date with everything going on

Join our mailing list