County Durham and Darlington Breast Care Review 

Free advice

Hundreds of patients suffered avoidable harm at County Durham and Darlington NHS Foundation Trust’s (CDDFT) breast service, including at least 20 women who underwent unnecessary mastectomies. The trust has agreed to review up to 4,500 additional cases dating back to 2015.

If you were treated at CDDFT, you don’t need to wait to hear from the trust to find out where you stand. We’re here to support you.

Speak to an Expert

CL Medilaw Logo

What is the County Durham breast care review?

In April 2025, the trust began reviewing breast care given between January 2023 and February 2025. So far, only 538 of the 1,472 cases from that period have been reviewed. Of those, 321 patients were were found to have been harmed and one patient died. The trust has found 20 unnecessary mastectomies, alongside a further 20 cases of delayed diagnoses.

Those findings cover just two years of care. The board has now agreed to review up to 4,500 more cases, potentially reviewing care going back to 2015. Independent reviews have found outdated diagnostic methods, high rates of repeat surgery, low rates of reconstruction, and an outsourcing deal that created a financial incentive to operate.

The trust has apologised and accepted the findings in full. If you were treated by the breast service in County Durham or Darlington and have concerns, we can help. That could include a breast cancer claim, unnecessary surgery, delays in treatment or different type of breast misdiagnosis.

reflective woman looks at the sunset after a cancer diagnosis
Midsection Of Woman With Hands Clasped Sitting On Bed In Hospital

Patients of Mr Amir Bhatti

Mr Amir Bhatti was the clinical lead for breast surgery at the trust. He was restricted from patient care in February 2025, and in May 2026 the High Court refused his application to have those restrictions lifted.

He is one of several clinicians whose care is being examined, and the review covers patients treated across the trust’s entire breast service. If you were treated by him, or by anyone else in the service, and you have concerns about your care, you can talk to us in confidence.

Private treatment at Spire Washington Hospital

Mr Bhatti also treated private patients at Spire Washington Hospital and no longer has practising privileges at any Spire hospital. Spire is running a patient recall with a dedicated helpline, and its patient notifications page explains how to get in touch.

How patients have been affected

Many women have described anger and a profound sense of betrayal over the impact of their treatment. They want to know how this happened and why it was allowed to continue. The reviews identified four main forms of avoidable harm.

Unnecessary or excessive surgery

The trust says 20 women underwent mastectomies they did not need, and its review identified other instances of excessive surgery. CDDFT has acknowledged that some patients received more extensive surgery than was clinically necessary.

The Royal College of Surgeons raised concerns about how the specialist team made treatment decisions and found that some operations proceeded with “great swiftness”. Women who lost a breast unnecessarily continue to face lasting physical and emotional consequences.

Repeat operations

The Royal College of Surgeons found that the trust was an outlier for repeat operations, known as re-excisions. These procedures are required when the first operation does not remove all cancerous tissue.

The trust says the number of patients requiring a second operation has halved since the service was overhauled. If you underwent multiple operations, we can assess whether better initial surgery could have prevented further unnecessary treatment.

Delayed diagnosis and outdated tests

The trust’s review identified 20 delayed diagnoses. In some cases, the delay may have allowed the cancer to spread.

The reviews found that the service used outdated practices, including fine needle aspiration — a diagnostic test the trust now reserves for exceptional cases. Delays can lead to more invasive treatment, reduce the chance of recovery, or both. If you were initially reassured but diagnosed later, it is worth asking why.

Breast reconstructions not offered

Women undergoing a mastectomy should be offered the opportunity to discuss immediate reconstruction. County Durham and Darlington NHS Foundation Trust’s rates were well below the national benchmark, although the trust says they have tripled since the service was overhauled.

CDDFT says some women who underwent unnecessary mastectomies may now be offered reconstruction. Not receiving that option at the time can affect how you feel about your body for years.

You do not need to wait for the trust to contact you

The review is progressing backwards one year at a time, so care provided longer ago may not be examined for several years. You do not need to wait for its findings before seeking independent legal advice.

Medical negligence claims are subject to strict time limits. You usually have three years from the treatment date, or from when you first knew — or could reasonably have known — that something had gone wrong. The trust’s review does not pause this deadline. If you have concerns, speak to us promptly so we can explain your options.

Close up of serious woman standing in semi position

Meet our Team

Our experienced team will be on hand to support you throughout the claim process.

How we’ve helped others

A second opinion on a delayed diagnosis

Another firm told our client her claim for a delayed breast cancer diagnosis wouldn’t succeed. We agreed to take another look, first obtaining expert evidence, before securing a full admission of liability to help settle her claim.

Unnecessary surgery after a misdiagnosis

VS had major surgery for cancer she didn’t have, after her biopsy results were mixed up with another patient’s. We secured an early admission of liability and interim payments while her claim progressed. Her claim settled for significant damages.

Get your free case assessment

We understand that discussing your care can be difficult and that contacting us takes trust. Your free case assessment begins with listening carefully to your experience before we explain the next steps.

With your agreement, we will:

  • Obtain and review your medical records.
  • Review any letters or findings you have received from the trust.
  • Give you an honest view on whether you may have a claim.

There is no obligation to continue. If we believe you have a claim and you choose to proceed, we will act for you on a no win, no fee basis. We can also provide a second opinion if another firm has said you do not have a case.

FAQs

Yes, many patients won’t be contacted for some time, and some might not be contacted at all. You can speak to us whenever you’re ready.

Yes, the trust’s review may review treatment as far back as 2015, but some patients treated earlier have raised concerns too. Time limits can be problematic, but they don’t always rule out a claim, so it’s worth contacting us.

Yes, the trust’s review includes patients treated across its breast service, not only those treated by one surgeon.

Yes, patients treated privately may be contacted by Spire but you can still get legal advice about your care.

Often, you won’t know without an independent review of your records. If anything about your diagnosis, surgery or treatment didn’t feel right, or you were later told things should have been done differently, it’s worth talking to us.

Yes, the trust’s helpline is open to anyone with concerns, whenever they were treated. You can call 0191 333 2126 or email cddft.breastservices@nhs.net.

No, making a claim won’t affect the care you receive.

We act on a no win, no fee basis, so you won’t pay legal fees if your claim isn’t successful. We’ll explain everything you need to know clearly at the start.